-
Bondholders as "loan to own" players.
The 1910 Virginia Glee Club: found, one director
I may have found a missing link in the Virginia Glee Club’s history prior to the 1920s, when it became a part of the McIntire Department of Music at the University of Virginia. As I’ve written before, the Club disbanded and reformed pretty frequently in the first two decades of the twentieth century, and we have evidence that the group came back together in 1910 following a hiatus of no more than four or five years. Now we know who led the group then–and it was a professor, not a student. (See my prior post on student directors of the Glee Club for some of the history there.)
A new volume of Madison Hall Notes, the journal of what was then the UVA branch of the YMCA, is on Google Books. In Vol. VI No. 7 (Oct 22, 1910) and Vol. VI No. 11 (Feb. 11, 1911) we read of the newly (re)formed Virginia Glee Club under the direction of Professor M.S. Remsburg. Hopefully I’ll turn up some more information on Remsburg and the efforts to rebuild the Club as more information from this era comes online.
Grab bag: Strategies and appropriations
-
A thoroughly thought out strategy guide to Othello from a master of the game.
-
I like the concept of an RT API, and I think the user experience sketches illustrated here are spot on. I also think that this is a great example of crowdsourced features–Twitter is slowly evolving from a generic messaging system to a highly evolved conversation system with the help of its users, who pioneer new features with social conventions and 140 characters.
-
Astonishing set of photos of the Harvard Museum of Natural History’s collection. I particularly liked Vladimir Nabokov’s butterfly collection, and the collection of tanagers which looks for all the world like Joseph Cornell put them together.
-
Clinton sounds a note of caution to net progressives: “Trying to hold the president’s feet to the fire is fine, but first we have to win the big argument. It’s ok with me if you want to keep everybody honest. But try to keep this thing in the lane of getting something done. We need to pass a bill.”
-
Another good reason to get an iPhone 3GS — the camera is just faster.
-
#blogpostfriday is a great idea. For me, the rest of the week is linkblogging. I try to actually write on Friday. The good news is, sometimes it spills over to the rest of the week.
Postcard from Madison County
Today’s post is a delayed peek at where I was the first week of August. We took a week’s vacation and spent it with my parents at their house in Buncombe County, as well as getting in a lot of good time with my aunt and uncle, cousins, and a rare visit with my Aunt Jewell. The photo above was taken at what I still think of as my grandmother’s farm (now my Aunt Jewell’s) in Madison County, as are a number of the other photos in the Flickr set I just posted. (Folks who are marked as friends and family in Flickr will find some new family photos in this set and in my photostream.)
Every time I go down there to visit, time slows a little bit. Part of this is because of the infrastructure in western North Carolina; though growth has accelerated in Buncombe County around Asheville, Madison remains the same deeply rural, underdeveloped county that maddened me as a bored child and entrances me and saddens me now. Part of it is the land and the quiet. Part of it used to be the isolation from technology, but my parents have had high speed for a while and before this visit they installed a wireless access point. I still managed to spend most of my time outside.
I sometimes think: so much of my job is virtual. What if I had to live in Asheville? I could probably do some of what I do, but sadly product management still requires a lot of face to face time with the various constituencies that we support. The refrain of “Free Man In Paris” goes through my mind every time I leave: “If I could I’d go back there tomorrow, but for the work I’ve taken on…”
(Of course, I’d miss other things about where we are, like being able to sing in the Tanglewood Festival Chorus. But our work is the main thing.)
Grab bag: Command and control
-
Nasty nasty nasty. Using base64 encoded tweets, that translate to tinyURLs, that download as zipped archives, that unpack with malicious payloads.
-
Detailed shootout of five Mac OS X page layout apps from smaller ISVs. I had to go through this exercise recently, and found I didn’t like the options that were out there. Will have to go back and look at iCalamus again.
-
Thoughts about having VCs in board meetings are not that different from having anybody in any meeting. Do you want to add value or just “give good body temperature”?
-
I think there’s an implicit “for now” on the end of that sentence, but I applaud the return of the single.
-
How proper fertilizing helped to reduce lead levels in the White House garden.
Grab bag: Cool, Newt, Lenny, and UI
-
This is what photoblogs should be like – indelible and just what they say. This is impossibly cool.
-
Shorter Gingrich: I was in favor of end of life care before I was calling it a “death panel.”
-
Leonard Bernstein’s FBI files reveal that he was perpetually under suspicion of being Communist and that Nixon called him a “son of a bitch.” Which, I suppose, is par for the course for a musician in the 1950s through the 1970s.
-
Excellent summary of UI design issues.
The first part of the 1921 Yellow Journal
I’m gradually scanning and uploading the pages of the April 1921 Yellow Journal, that scurrilous anonymous satirical broadside at the University of Virginia. This morning I’ve uploaded pages 1 through 4 along with an index of the stories. The pages available through my site are 100dpi PNG files; TIFFs have also been produced.
For now, these are scans of photocopies, as I’m reluctant to subject the fragile newsprint to my color scanner directly (mostly because every time I unfold it I run the risk of cracking the pages). I intend to get scans of the original artifact, but these black and white copies hopefully give some flavor of what the original is like.
My favorite excerpt from the issue so far may be the one liner on page 3: “Mike Wagenheim says that Norfolk is the greatest town in this state. Quite right. No other town could be in the state that Norfolk is in.”
Naked attempts at subverting the public discourse
-
The question is: Would you like your care rationed by the government or by private industry?
Grab bag: FriendFeed acquired
-
Real time search on Facebook. Actually, ANY search on posts on Facebook is good news; real time is just icing.
-
Wow, that’s different–and this is maybe how Facebook gets out of being a walled garden–by bringing the rest of the Internet into its profiles. Hopefully that’s not all it does.
-
A way forward out of the disintegration of discourse–just do it like Jon Stewart does it.
-
Fallows on the shift in public discourse on healthcare to virulent misinformation.
-
Ancestral cemetary for a few generations of the Jarrett family.
-
Incredible untold story from the Big Dig–and it’s only halfway presented this week. Two dead in a tunnel under Boston Harbor…
-
The real danger of this full court press against health care reform is that it poisons every single legitimate tool of representative government.
The death of tr.im, or why you are your own product manager
The recent flap over the impending death of tr.im reminds me of a discussion I had at the Berkman Center when I crashed one of their meetings back in 2004. The question was, do you use external services with your blog? That is, do you host your images on Flickr or a related service? Do you outsource comment management? These days, the question is do you host your own videos or do you let YouTube do it; or do you use a URL shortener.
Fundamentally, these are strategic questions like the ones that product managers face every day. The question is “Build, Buy, or Partner?” and it’s a question about how you add functionality to your product offering. In this case, the “product offering” is your public presence on the Internet–which is to say, in public, on-the-record discourse. As the question is conventionally understood, “build” means build it yourself, “buy” means acquire the functionality via some sort of purchase of rights, and “partner” means make a business arrangement where the partner delivers the functionality directly. In web development terms:
- Build: You can build most of the functionality that people use on the web, from photo galleries to URL shorteners, yourself if you are a reasonably competent programmer.
- Buy: You are acquiring via a license (even a free one) functionality from a third party and providing that functionality to your users. Can include purchased software or free software, whole packages or plugins.
- Partner: You are using third party services directly–embedding photos and video from someone else’s server, using a third party URL shortener, etc.
So how do you decide to build, buy or partner? You can ask yourself the same questions that product managers everywhere ask:
- Do I have the capability to create this functionality?
- Do I want the responsibility of maintaining this functionality and adding to it over the long run?
- Is this functionality a core part of what I do? Do I derive some sort of competitive advantage from it?
- How much control over the final product do I want?
- Can I afford to have the content go away?
If you can do #1 but not #2, buy might be a better option than build. If the answer to #4 is “a lot”, partnering is not an appropriate option.
Let’s look at some people’s reactions to the event in this light:
Dave Winer had chosen the “partnership” model with tr.im (in the sense described above, that he is using their services and building atop them), building a lot of functionality on top of their APIs. He sees tr.im’s collapse as an argument to eliminate URL shorteners altogether, or at least to require that they provide a portability option. Portability is a way that you can escape Question #5, a safety clause if the partner goes out of business or if you don’t like what they’re doing with your content. I think that shortened-URL portability is in this analogy the equivalent of source code escrow and other safety provisions in conventional software contracts–it’s your escape hatch to make sure your personal data isn’t threatened. This is a perfectly sane request if you’re entering a real partnership relationship, where you’re adding value to the other party’s offering.
By contrast, Jeffrey Zeldman went the “buy” path, installing a WordPress URL shortening plugin to share pointers to his own content. For him, having short links to his content that work indefinitely is too important to risk having “the third-party URL shortening site [go] down or [go] out of business.”
Looking at it through the build-buy-partner lens, it’s also easy to see why WordPress has become such a dominant platform. The ability to add third-party developed plugins to add functionality provides a wide variety of options to add new functionality and allows you more options than simply blindly partnering with another organization, without any assurance that they’ll continue to support you.
Why go down this path at all? Why worry about the longevity of what are almost certainly transient services? One way to look at it is this: at the end of the day, your web presence is your product, and you are its product manager. You are responsible for the strategy that determines how the world views you. And in that light, it makes sense to borrow some strategies from product management to plan that strategy. Others use the formulation “You are your own CEO”; as your own CEO, consider that what people interact with online is not you but a product.
Grab bag: the success of fail
-
To read.
-
The success of FAIL.
-
Key to building anything–take notes as you go.
Grab bag: The August everything fell apart?
-
Useful runthrough and disemboweling of various talking points against the administration’s healthcare proposals.
-
On the current healthcare riots vs. the Social Security discussions: “Indeed, activists made trouble in 2005 by asking Congressmen tough questions about policy. Activists are making trouble now by shouting Congressmen down so they can’t be heard.”
-
It’s always nice to see going after the truth in a more confrontational way than “he said, she said” journalism usually does, but this is great.
-
I would be irresponsible if I didn’t post the mildest example of this phenomenon, as spotted on Twitter: “If Bill Clinton wants to bring two girls home, not even North Korea can stop him.” I’m very impressed with the rescue operation, seriously, but there’s no way the jokes won’t come, “derangement syndrome” or no.
-
Julie Powell’s reflection on the water under the bridge.
-
The comments section sums up the attack on Julie Powell nicely. The attacks are childish, mean-spirited, and more than a little sour-grapes. I remember reading the original blog avidly back in the day, and can’t wait to see the movie.
-
Using unsupported formats in iTunes. Looks good until you try to sync to an iPod.
-
An optimistic view of the likelihood of IE6 going away. To which I say: yes, but if the corporate intranet applications all break under IE7 (not unlikely), it’ll be a cold day in hell before the poor users ever see a real browser.
-
Harry Patch was 109.
Grab bag: Mouthwatering edition
-
An interesting modern food blog regarding the legendary beef bourguignon recipe from Julia Child. Mouthwatering reading. Makes me want to cook with beef cheeks.
-
Probably won’t ever get to the point where oyster shells will again be a common paving material instead of gravel for rural roads, but any rebound of the population is promising.
-
Proof there are still arrows in the ex-President’s quiver.
Grab bag: Attention to detail edition
-
I read Cooks Illustrated religiously until I got the sense they were returning to the same ground over and over again. Seems like there’s a reason for that.
-
Easy to use hex editor for the Mac. Design goal: “This app is about exploring the implementation of standard desktop UI features in the realm of files too large to fully read into main memory. Is it possible to do copy and paste, find and replace, undo and redo, on a document that may top a hundred gigabytes, and make it feel natural?”
-
Awesome shot of Julie & Julia author Julie Powell with the mother of all whisks.
Shocked, shocked at shoddy BIOS security
-
LoJack is the sort of software that should be absolutely above reproach, because it’s used in a hostile attacker scenario and lives at a very very low level of the operating system. That it is easily hackable is, um, troubling.